GRAETER'S ICE CREAM

GRAETER'S ICE CREAM

multiple locations, graeters.com

After relinquishing the title last year, Graeter's fought back to reclaim their perch atop the big ice-cream sundae. Was it the new line of gelatos that won them favor with Columbus parents or just our fondness for those signature chip ice creams?

RUNNERS-UP: Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams, Whit's Frozen Custard

THE 5-PERCENT CLUB: Dairy Queen, Johnson's Real Ice Cream