DONATO'S

DONATO'S

multiple locations

donatos.com

Yeah, we're "homers" when it comes to our pizza-delivery options. Columbus-born and -raised Donato's, now in its 51st year of operation, takes the win for the fourth year in a row.

RUNNERS-UP: Jet's, Tommy's

HONORABLE MENTION: Brooklyn Pizza, Eagles Pizza, Flyers Pizza & Subs, Hounddog's Pizza, Massey's Pizza, Mikey's Late Night Slice, Pizza Cottage, Romeo's Pizza, Taranto's Pizza